The ecosystem of virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR) in Europe is constantly evolving, with significant potential to transform key sectors such as art, entertainment, education, healthcare, and manufacturing. The research on this topic has been conducted by a team of experts from the Danish Technological Institute, in collaboration with the Directorate-General for Communications Networks, Content and Technology of the European Commission. The project also involved academic and industrial partners, including the Fraunhofer Institute in Germany and the University of Tampere in Finland, providing multidisciplinary expertise and strategic resources. Furthermore, the project benefited from contributions by leading industry companies such as Varjo and Lynx, which provided technical support and access to state-of-the-art technologies, significantly enhancing the impact of the research.
Technological and Economic Context
Europe has demonstrated considerable innovation capacity in the VR/AR sector, but it is currently limited by a significant dependence on non-European platforms and hardware, primarily from the United States and East Asia. This imbalance is particularly evident in the context of digital platforms for the distribution of VR/AR content and hardware manufacturers, such as headsets and sensors, which are dominated by non-European companies.
According to the "VR/AR Industrial Coalition Strategic Paper" by the European Commission, the European VR/AR market in 2021 was estimated at approximately €7.1 billion, with a growth of 26% compared to the previous year. By 2026, the European market is expected to grow at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 37%, with an estimated total value between €35 and €65 billion and direct employment ranging from 440,000 to 860,000 people. Among the key hubs, Paris, Laval, Berlin, Munich, Amsterdam, Helsinki, Madrid, Barcelona, and Milan are reference points for the sector, with strong local ecosystems capable of supporting innovation and the development of new technological solutions.
This growth rate is supported by a series of technological developments, such as the adoption of new software platforms, the development of more efficient hardware, and the expansion of high-quality content.
Currently, Europe holds a leadership position in content development and research, with relevant players such as the Fraunhofer Institute and the University of Tampere playing a central role. However, hardware production is dominated by foreign technology giants. Companies such as Meta (formerly Oculus), HTC, Sony, and Microsoft control most of the hardware market, while Europe remains competitive only with a few niche companies such as Varjo (Finland) and Lynx (France), which produce high-tech hardware but with limited volumes compared to major global competitors.
The growth of VR/AR in Europe is also influenced by the adoption of technological infrastructure such as 5G networks, essential for improving the usability of immersive experiences. According to the report, the rollout of 5G is still delayed in many EU Member States, with intermediate targets for 2020 reached by only four countries. Widespread 5G coverage is crucial for enabling high-quality streaming and an overall improvement in VR/AR technologies' performance, especially in industrial and healthcare environments.
On the economic challenges side, funding for VR/AR start-ups remains a delicate issue. Between 2010 and 2021, European companies in the sector raised almost €400 million, with an increase of over 80% from 2019 to 2021. However, these figures are significantly lower than investments in the United States, where the sector attracted over €25 billion in the same period. Difficulties in accessing venture capital and the lack of private funding in Europe represent major obstacles to the growth of emerging companies in the VR/AR sector. Most funding is concentrated in the early stages (seed and early-stage VC), with few opportunities for growth for companies that need subsequent funding rounds to scale their operations.
In terms of technological development, the production of VR/AR-related patents in Europe is relatively limited compared to other regions of the world. The main European countries involved in research and development of VR/AR technologies include Finland, France, Germany, and the Netherlands, with companies such as Nokia, Siemens, Philips, and Ericsson at the forefront in terms of patents in the sector. Despite these advances, most innovation in the VR/AR sector is still concentrated in the United States and Asia, highlighting the need for Europe to invest more in research and development to bridge the technological gap.
Application Sectors of VR/AR
Creative and Visual Arts
VR and AR technologies are opening new horizons for creative and visual arts, providing advanced tools that allow artists to create works in three-dimensional environments, surpassing the limits of the traditional two-dimensional canvas. These new tools are not only means for digital art but also represent a new immersive experience for viewers. For example, tools such as TiltBrush and Quill allow artists to paint directly in VR, creating unique visual works that can be distributed in both virtual and physical contexts. According to the "VR/AR Industrial Coalition Strategic Paper," the creative arts sector accounts for about 10% of the total VR/AR market in Europe, thanks to the growing popularity of immersive experiences in museums, art galleries, and cultural spaces.
Entertainment and Media
In the entertainment sector, VR is used to create immersive storytelling experiences, transforming the user from a passive observer to an active part of the narrative. A significant example is VR concerts, such as the one by Finnish band Nightwish, which saw over 150,000 attendees in a virtual environment created by Zoan. The ability of VR to create empathy and engagement offers new possibilities for cinema, television, and even journalism, making stories more engaging and immediate. The VR/AR market for entertainment and media in Europe is estimated at around €1.32 billion, representing 18.6% of the total market. Growth in this sector is closely linked to the expansion of the video game market and the demand for immersive video content.
Healthcare and Training
In healthcare, VR is used for training and education of doctors and medical staff, providing the opportunity to simulate complex clinical scenarios in a safe environment. Projects such as that of the University of Tampere use VR to represent three-dimensional structures of organs and tissues, improving the effectiveness of diagnostic and therapeutic procedures. The adoption of VR in healthcare helps reduce costs associated with traditional training and improves the quality of medical training. According to data from the European Commission, the use of VR for surgical training can reduce learning times by 40% compared to traditional methods. The healthcare sector is one of the main beneficiaries of VR/AR technologies, with an estimated annual growth rate of 27%. Immersive technologies are also used for patient rehabilitation, pain management, and the treatment of phobias and mental disorders, with positive results in terms of reducing discomfort and improving patients' quality of life.
Manufacturing and Construction
VR and AR technologies are also widely used in manufacturing and construction, sectors where they are employed to optimize design processes, improve worker training, and increase operational efficiency. AR, in particular, is used to overlay digital information on physical components during assembly processes, improving precision and reducing errors. According to the "VR/AR Industrial Coalition Strategic Paper," the adoption of these technologies in manufacturing could generate up to a 20% increase in production efficiency, significantly reducing downtime and maintenance costs. In the construction sector, VR is used to create detailed project simulations, allowing clients to virtually explore buildings and spaces before they are built. This approach not only improves communication between designers, clients, and workers but also reduces the margin for error during the construction phase. It is estimated that the adoption of VR/AR in the construction industry could reduce project revision costs by up to 25%, contributing to better resource utilization.
Retail and E-Commerce
In the retail sector, augmented reality is mainly used to enhance customer experience, for example, by allowing them to visualize how a piece of furniture might look in a particular space or how an item of clothing might fit a person. The IKEA Place app is a striking example: using AR technology, it allows customers to visualize products at scale directly in their home environment, improving the shopping experience and reducing returns. The value of the VR/AR market in the retail sector is estimated at €0.9 billion and is expected to grow at a CAGR of 35% by 2026, as more companies begin to adopt these technologies to offer immersive and personalized shopping experiences. The growing interest in the metaverse is further pushing investments in this direction, with the creation of virtual stores where users can interact with products as they would in a physical store.
Education and Learning
In education, VR and AR technologies are becoming essential tools for improving learning effectiveness. Immersive experiences allow students to explore complex concepts interactively, enhancing comprehension and retention. For instance, history lessons can be enriched with virtual tours of historical sites, while science classes can be integrated with 3D simulations of experiments that are otherwise difficult to conduct in a traditional classroom. According to the "VR/AR Industrial Coalition Strategic Paper," the education sector is set to grow significantly, with VR/AR technology adoption rates expected to reach 60% in high schools and universities by 2030. This growth is supported by European Union initiatives aimed at enhancing digital skills and promoting the use of advanced technologies in schools and training centers.
Challenges and Opportunities
The European VR/AR ecosystem faces several challenges, but at the same time, significant opportunities are emerging that could allow it to grow and become a global leader. One of the main obstacles is dependence on non-European technologies and platforms. This situation limits not only Europe's autonomy but also its ability to compete effectively at the international level, negatively impacting VR/AR content monetization and distribution models.
Another crucial challenge is access to funding. European start-ups in the VR/AR sector struggle to attract significant venture capital. This makes it difficult for companies to scale their operations and compete with major global players, which receive far more funding. For example, while European companies in the sector raised about €400 million between 2010 and 2021, their counterparts in the United States attracted over €25 billion in the same period.
The fragmentation of the European market represents another obstacle for the VR/AR sector. The lack of common standards and interoperability among different Member States limits the sector's efficiency and competitiveness, reducing the ability to innovate and scale quickly. A coordinated European approach could promote the creation of shared standards, improve interoperability, and reduce barriers among different national markets.
In terms of skills, the sector suffers from a shortage of specialized talent, especially in disciplines requiring advanced technical skills such as programming, hardware design, and immersive content development. This skills gap hampers the sector's development and makes it difficult for companies to find the qualified personnel they need to grow. Academic training and investment in digital skills development programs are therefore crucial for the future of VR/AR in Europe.
Despite these challenges, there are also significant opportunities for the European VR/AR sector. The adoption of technological infrastructures such as 5G networks is crucial to improving access to high-quality immersive experiences, especially in industrial and healthcare contexts. The expansion of 5G networks in Europe could enable more efficient streaming and improved performance for VR/AR technologies, facilitating the adoption of these solutions in various sectors.
Moreover, collaborations between companies, academic institutions, and research centers are key to accelerating innovation. Public-private partnerships can provide resources, knowledge, and funding, creating a favorable environment for the development of the sector.
Finally, the focus on sustainability and ethics in the development of VR/AR technologies represents an opportunity to differentiate the European industry from global competitors. Promoting high-quality, ethical, and sustainable solutions can increase Europe's competitiveness and attract both public and private investments, as well as improve the perceived value of immersive technologies among consumers and businesses.
The Impact of Generative Artificial Intelligence on the VR/AR Market
The introduction of generative artificial intelligence (generative AI) is changing the virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR) market, as highlighted by recent international academic research from 2024. These studies underline how generative AI is transforming content creation, improving interactivity, and personalizing user experiences in VR/AR environments. The ability of generative AI to automate the production of complex and realistic virtual environments significantly reduces development time and costs. For example, the concept of Neural Radiance Fields (NeRFs) enables the generation of photorealistic 3D scenes from 2D images, facilitating the creation of immersive content without the need for detailed manual modeling. This progress makes the production of high-quality experiences accessible even to those with limited resources.
Generative AI also enables dynamic personalization of VR/AR experiences, adapting content to user preferences and actions. In the educational sector, virtual assistants based on generative AI can provide personalized explanations and support, improving learning effectiveness in immersive environments and creating a more suitable learning path for each student's individual needs. This makes tailored learning possible, which is particularly important for specialized fields such as medicine and engineering, where the need for realistic practical experiences is crucial. VR enriched by generative AI not only improves the quality of training but also makes it more accessible, as personalized content can be tailored to each individual's skills and learning pace.
The integration of generative AI into VR/AR also enhances interactivity, allowing the creation of virtual characters capable of responding naturally to human interactions. This progress is particularly relevant in the entertainment and training sectors, where the presence of intelligent virtual agents enriches the user experience, making it more engaging and realistic. Non-playable characters (NPCs) in gaming environments can now be equipped with generative AI, allowing them to respond with personalized dialogue and adaptive behaviors that change based on user interaction. This way, game narratives become non-linear, evolving in response to players' choices, creating a truly unique experience for each user.
In healthcare, generative AI can be used to develop realistic simulations for medical training. Surgical simulations, for instance, can be customized to represent specific cases and patient conditions, providing doctors with more targeted and detailed training opportunities. Furthermore, VR-based rehabilitation programs can be enhanced by generative AI, which can adapt exercises and rehabilitation scenarios based on the progress and needs of the individual patient, making the therapeutic path more effective and specific. This kind of adaptability not only improves the effectiveness of therapies but also allows real-time progress monitoring, continuously adapting the treatment for optimal results.
In the commercial and retail sectors, generative AI enables the creation of immersive shopping experiences tailored to each customer. For example, it will be possible to automatically generate virtual environments that reflect the user's stylistic preferences and tastes, increasing the likelihood of conversion and improving the overall customer experience. Virtual stores will be able to adapt in real time, showing users products that best match their preferences, based not only on direct interactions but also on data analysis gathered during previous experiences. The creation of virtual assistants powered by generative AI will also make it possible to provide more interactive and personalized customer support. Virtual assistants will be able to answer customer questions more naturally and contextually, improving service quality and contributing to a smoother and more satisfying shopping experience.
From a content production perspective, generative AI allows for cost reductions by automating processes that would normally require hours of human work. Artists and developers can now focus their efforts on creative aspects, while AI takes care of generating basic details such as textures, environments, and even sound elements. This significantly speeds up development times and makes it possible to explore a broader range of creative ideas, as limitations related to production times and costs are reduced. Additionally, tools like DALL-E and Midjourney, based on generative AI, allow for the generation of concept art that can be used directly or as a basis for further development.
Despite the numerous benefits, the integration of generative AI in VR/AR also presents significant challenges. One of the main challenges is ensuring the quality and consistency of generated content. Since AI operates on large amounts of data, it is essential to ensure that this data is high-quality and free from biases to avoid generating distorted or discriminatory content. Moreover, the use of generative AI also raises ethical issues related to the intellectual property of automatically created content, user privacy, and potential dependency on technology. Developing ethical guidelines and standards is therefore crucial to ensure a responsible and sustainable use of these technologies, promoting a balance between innovation and responsibility.
In summary, research clearly highlights how generative AI is transforming the VR/AR market, offering opportunities for innovative content creation, personalized experiences, and advanced interactivity. The ability to create virtual environments and characters that adapt in real-time to user needs represents a turning point in how technology is used in entertainment, education, and healthcare contexts.
Conclusions
VR/AR in Europe is not just a set of technological tools and market opportunities; it represents a cultural shift towards a new kind of perception, presence, and human experience that redefines not only the boundaries of innovation but also those of Europe's collective consciousness. In a continent marked by a long history of cultural identities and philosophical visions, VR/AR is not merely an industry but a field where Europe can rediscover a contemporary form of its "digital humanism." The adoption of VR/AR in areas such as art, education, and entertainment, for example, may not be so much a move towards the technology itself as an entry into a new narrative and interpretative dimension, where the "virtual" and the "real" are no longer distinct but co-created through user interaction.
A cultural question arises here: how can Europe transform this immersive revolution into an extension of its cultural vision, rather than a mere imitation of non-European technologies? After all, the integration of these technologies opens up spaces for narratives that are no longer linear and no longer necessarily dominated by conventional visual or physical language, but open to infinite expressive modalities, capable of bringing cultural heritage back to life, reinterpreting works of art, bringing the past to life, or simulating possible futures. Augmented and virtual reality has the potential to evolve education and cultural communication, going beyond simple digital learning: these technologies place the individual at the center of an experiential environment where it is possible to actively explore European identity, connecting different eras, values, and perspectives.
However, this evolution also raises a challenge of self-representation for Europe. What does it mean for Europe to tell its story in a virtual space? VR/AR technology is not neutral; it structures and selects both experience and knowledge. The models created, the interfaces used, and even the platforms used for these experiences become means of transmitting visions and forms of control. In other words, if Europe does not develop its own autonomous technological identity, it risks adopting digital structures that transmit foreign values, threatening to distance people from their cultural experience. Rather than representing a channel of cultural and identity discovery, VR/AR could become a filter that applies a veneer of "Europeanization" to values or images conceived elsewhere.
In this scenario, one of the real challenges for Europe is not just technological or economic scalability but the ability to create a digital cultural infrastructure that reflects its historical and social specificities. For example, imagining VR/AR experiences that represent narrative visions or forms of interaction unique to European philosophy or art, in a fusion between humanistic roots and digital technologies, would mean building a European language of virtual reality. A language that does not merely impose global technological narratives but allows Europe's past to become a laboratory of meanings and interactions for the future.
Ultimately, the real question is not whether Europe can compete in VR/AR production but whether it can use this technology to evolve and transmit its cultural heritage, creating a new digital "European presence." It is a strategic challenge that involves the very definition of identity, memory, and innovation, seeking a balance between technological autonomy and the ability to reinterpret and share its cultural imagination in an "augmented" and shared reality.
コメント